Rammohan Roy, the Brahmo Samaj and the Prarthana Samaj
Rammohan Roy, Brahmo Sabha (1828), the 1866 and 1878 Brahmo splits, Young Bengal and the Prarthana Samaj (1867) for CGPSC Prelims and Mains.
Prerequisites
- British Expansion and Colonial Policies: Company rule in Bengal, English education and the Charter Acts. These are the setting the reformers responded to.
- Bhakti and Sufi Movements: the older Indian tradition of questioning ritual and caste. The 19th-century reformers often drew on it.
- Socio-Religious Reform Movements: chapter overview: the map of the whole chapter.
The Hook: A Tract Written in Persian
Around 1803–04, a young revenue official in Murshidabad wrote a short tract in Persian, with a preface in Arabic, arguing that all religions share a belief in one God and that their rituals and miracles were added later. The tract was Tuhfat-ul-Muwahhidin (“A Gift to Monotheists”). Its author, Rammohan Roy, would go on to found the first modern reform society in India.
Why did a Bengali Brahmin trained in Persian and Sanskrit end up attacking idol worship and campaigning against sati? And why did his society split twice within fifty years?
Why it matters: Prelims asks for exact founders, years and splits (1828, 1866, 1878), and for the Sati Regulation of 1829. Mains asks you to assess the reformers: their methods, their limits, and their role in preparing the ground for nationalism.
The Setting: Why Reform Began in Bengal
- Bengal was the first region under direct Company rule (after Plassey, 1757, and the Diwani, 1765). Calcutta was the capital of British India.
- A new English-educated middle class grew up there. It worked in Company offices, trade and the professions.
- Western rationalism, the printing press and newspapers, and Christian missionary criticism of Hindu practice all reached Calcutta first.
- Reformers used reason and the authority of old texts together. They argued that evils such as sati were not sanctioned by the original scriptures.
This is often called the Bengal Renaissance (बंगाल पुनर्जागरण).
Raja Rammohan Roy (राजा राममोहन राय), 1772–1833
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Born | 1772, Radhanagar, Hooghly district, Bengal |
| Languages | Bengali, Sanskrit, Persian, Arabic, English (and others) |
| Title “Raja” | Given by the Mughal emperor Akbar II, who sent him to England (1830) to plead for an increase in his pension |
| Died | 1833, at Bristol, England |
| Called | “Father of the Indian Renaissance”; “Father of modern India” in many textbooks |
Organisations and writings
| Year | Work or body | Point to remember |
|---|---|---|
| c. 1803–04 | Tuhfat-ul-Muwahhidin | Persian tract (Arabic preface) for monotheism |
| 1814 / 1815 | Atmiya Sabha (आत्मीय सभा), Calcutta | Discussion circle for monotheism; sources differ on 1814 or 1815 |
| 1820 | Precepts of Jesus | Took the moral teaching of Jesus but rejected miracles and the Trinity. This drew him into argument with Christian missionaries |
| 1821 | Sambad Kaumudi | Bengali weekly, used in the anti-sati campaign |
| 1822 | Mirat-ul-Akhbar | Persian weekly |
| 20 August 1828 | Brahmo Sabha (ब्रह्म सभा), Calcutta | Later renamed the Brahmo Samaj (ब्रह्म समाज) |
What the Brahmo Samaj stood for
- One formless God (monotheism), worshipped without idols, priests or sacrifices.
- Authority of the Upanishads read through reason. Rammohan translated several Upanishads into Bengali and English.
- Open to people of every faith for worship. No image, no sermon reviling another religion.
- Opposition to caste rigidity, polygamy, sati and the denial of property rights to women.
Social reform and politics
- Sati (सती प्रथा): He campaigned against it from around 1818 through tracts and petitions. Governor-General Lord William Bentinck passed the Bengal Sati Regulation (Regulation XVII), 4 December 1829, making sati illegal and punishable.
- The orthodox Dharma Sabha (1830) of Radhakanta Deb appealed to the Privy Council against the ban. Rammohan, then in England, worked to defend it, and the appeal failed.
- Education: He supported English and scientific education. He ran an Anglo-Hindu School (1822) and a Vedanta College (1825), combining Western science with Indian learning.
- Press freedom: He protested against the Press Ordinance of 1823 (the Adam Regulation) that required a licence to publish.
- Women’s rights: He argued for women’s inheritance rights and against polygamy.
The Brahmo Samaj after Rammohan
flowchart TD
A["Brahmo Sabha, 1828
Rammohan Roy"] --> B["Brahmo Samaj revived
Debendranath Tagore
(joined 1842–43)"]
B --> C["Split 1866"]
C --> D["Adi Brahmo Samaj
Debendranath Tagore"]
C --> E["Brahmo Samaj of India
Keshab Chandra Sen"]
E --> F["Split 1878
(Cooch Behar marriage)"]
F --> G["Sadharan Brahmo Samaj
15 May 1878
Ananda Mohan Bose, Sivanath Sastri"]
F --> H["Keshab: Naba Bidhan
(New Dispensation), 1880"]Debendranath Tagore (देवेंद्रनाथ टैगोर), 1817–1905
- Father of Rabindranath Tagore.
- Founded the Tattvabodhini Sabha (1839) and later merged it with the Brahmo Samaj, which he joined in the early 1840s and revived.
- The Tattvabodhini Patrika (Bengali journal) spread rational, Upanishadic religion. Akshay Kumar Datta was a well-known editor.
- He gave up belief in the infallibility of the Vedas and kept the Samaj focused on religion rather than radical social change.
Keshab Chandra Sen (केशवचंद्र सेन), 1838–1884
- Joined the Brahmo Samaj in 1857. A powerful orator who took the movement beyond Bengal, to Bombay, Madras and the north.
- Pushed social reform: inter-caste marriage, widow remarriage, women’s education, and removal of the sacred thread by Brahmo ministers.
- First split, 1866: Debendranath’s group became the Adi Brahmo Samaj. Keshab formed the Brahmo Samaj of India.
- Founded the Indian Reform Association (1870). His campaign led to the Native Marriage Act, 1872 (often called the Brahmo Marriage Act). It allowed civil marriages for those who did not profess the established religions, fixed the minimum age at 14 for girls and 18 for boys, and forbade polygamy.
- Second split, 1878: Keshab married his under-age daughter to the young Maharaja of Cooch Behar with Hindu rites, against the Act he had championed. His followers broke away and formed the Sadharan Brahmo Samaj (15 May 1878), led by Ananda Mohan Bose and Sivanath Sastri, among others.
- In 1880 Keshab announced the Naba Bidhan (नव विधान, “New Dispensation”), drawing on several faiths.
Young Bengal
- Led by Henry Louis Vivian Derozio (1809–1831), a teacher at the Hindu College, Calcutta.
- His students questioned religion, custom and authority, inspired by the French Revolution and radical Western thought.
- Derozio was removed from the college in 1831 and died the same year. The movement was radical but had little mass base.
Reform in Western India: the Prarthana Samaj
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Precursor | Paramahansa Mandali (Bombay, 1849), a secret society against caste and idol worship |
| Founded | Prarthana Samaj (प्रार्थना समाज), Bombay, 1867 |
| Founder | Dr. Atmaram Pandurang, inspired by Keshab Chandra Sen’s visit |
| Leading members | Mahadev Govind Ranade, R.G. Bhandarkar, N.G. Chandavarkar |
| Religious root | Theism, with roots in the Maharashtrian bhakti tradition (Namdev, Tukaram) rather than a break with Hinduism |
| Social programme | Women’s education, widow remarriage, raising the marriage age, opposition to caste |
M.G. Ranade (महादेव गोविंद रानडे), 1842–1901: judge, economist and reformer. Associated with the Widow Remarriage Association (1861), the Deccan Education Society (1884) and the Indian National Social Conference (1887), which met alongside the early Congress sessions.
Analysis for Mains: Contribution and Limits
| Contribution | Limits |
|---|---|
| Attacked sati, polygamy, child marriage and caste rigidity; secured laws (1829, 1872) | Followers were few: urban, English-educated, mostly upper-caste |
| Brought reason into religious debate; translated scriptures into the people’s languages | Splits (1866, 1878) weakened the movement |
| Built a modern public sphere: newspapers, societies, petitions, debates | Relied on the colonial state for legislation |
| Gave Indians confidence that their own tradition could be reformed from within | Little impact on peasants, tribal communities and lower castes |
| Prepared the ground for political organisation and nationalism | Often seen by the orthodox as too close to Christianity and the British |
Memory Tricks
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Atmiya Sabha (1814/15), Rammohan’s discussion circle | vs | Brahmo Sabha (1828), the formal society |
| Tattvabodhini Sabha (1839), Debendranath | vs | Dharma Sabha (1830), Radhakanta Deb, orthodox, against the sati ban |
| Adi Brahmo Samaj (Debendranath, after 1866) | vs | Sadharan Brahmo Samaj (1878, broke away from Keshab) |
| Native Marriage Act 1872 (Brahmo; 14/18) | vs | Sarda Act 1929 (Child Marriage Restraint; also 14/18, but for all of British India) |
| Prarthana Samaj (Bombay, 1867, theistic, bhakti roots) | vs | Arya Samaj (Bombay, 1875, Vedic authority) |
Common Mistakes
- “Debendranath Tagore co-founded the Brahmo Sabha in 1828.” Wrong. He was a boy in 1828. He joined and revived the Samaj in the early 1840s.
- “Sati was abolished in 1829 by Lord Dalhousie.” Wrong. It was Lord William Bentinck, Regulation XVII of 1829.
- “The Sadharan Brahmo Samaj was founded by Keshab Chandra Sen.” Wrong. It was formed against Keshab, after the Cooch Behar marriage.
- “The title ‘Raja’ was given to Rammohan by the British.” Wrong. It was given by the Mughal emperor Akbar II.
- “The Prarthana Samaj was founded by M.G. Ranade.” Ranade was its most famous member, but the founder was Atmaram Pandurang (1867).
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CGPSC style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Rammohan Roy’s Persian tract on monotheism was titled ______.
- Sati was declared illegal by Regulation ______ of 1829 under Governor-General ______.
- The Sadharan Brahmo Samaj was formed in the year ______.
Answers
- Tuhfat-ul-Muwahhidin (“A Gift to Monotheists”).
- Regulation XVII; Lord William Bentinck.
- 1878 (15 May 1878).
Level 2: Prelims MCQs
Q1. Consider the following statements about Keshab Chandra Sen:
- He founded the Brahmo Samaj of India after the split of 1866.
- The Native Marriage Act, 1872 was passed as a result of his campaign.
- He led the Sadharan Brahmo Samaj formed in 1878.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 only
- (b) 1 and 2 only
- (c) 2 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
Q2. Match List I (Organisation) with List II (Founder or leader):
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. Tattvabodhini Sabha | 1. Radhakanta Deb |
| B. Dharma Sabha | 2. Atmaram Pandurang |
| C. Prarthana Samaj | 3. Debendranath Tagore |
| D. Atmiya Sabha | 4. Rammohan Roy |
- (a) A-3, B-1, C-2, D-4
- (b) A-1, B-3, C-2, D-4
- (c) A-3, B-1, C-4, D-2
- (d) A-4, B-1, C-2, D-3
Answer and explanation
Q3. Which of the following newspapers was published by Rammohan Roy in Persian?
- (a) Sambad Kaumudi
- (b) Mirat-ul-Akhbar
- (c) Tattvabodhini Patrika
- (d) Rast Goftar
Answer and explanation
Q4. The Young Bengal movement is associated with:
- (a) Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar
- (b) Henry Louis Vivian Derozio
- (c) Akshay Kumar Datta
- (d) Sivanath Sastri
Answer and explanation
Level 3: Mains Answer Writing
Q1. (150–200 words) “Raja Rammohan Roy was the first modern man of India.” Examine his contribution to social and religious reform.
Model answer outline
- Intro: Rammohan Roy (1772–1833) combined Indian scriptural learning with Western rationalism. He is called the father of the Indian Renaissance.
- Body:
- Religious: monotheism, rejection of idolatry and ritual; Tuhfat-ul-Muwahhidin; Atmiya Sabha; Brahmo Sabha (1828).
- Social: campaign against sati, leading to Regulation XVII (1829); support for women’s property rights; opposition to polygamy and caste rigidity.
- Education: support for English and scientific education alongside Vedanta.
- Political liberalism: protest against the Press Ordinance of 1823; demand for rule of law and Indian participation.
- Method: reason plus scriptural argument, petitions and the press, a model later reformers followed.
- Limits: small, urban, upper-caste following; reliance on the colonial state.
- Conclusion: He set the agenda of 19th-century reform and opened the way to a modern, questioning public life in India.
Q2. (60 words) Why did the Brahmo Samaj split in 1866 and 1878?
Model answer outline
- 1866: Keshab Chandra Sen wanted radical social reform (inter-caste marriage, removing the sacred thread) and a wider mission. Debendranath preferred gradual change, so his group became the Adi Brahmo Samaj.
- 1878: Keshab married his under-age daughter to the Maharaja of Cooch Behar, against the 1872 Act he had promoted. His followers formed the Sadharan Brahmo Samaj.
- Conclusion: Each split was about how far and how fast social reform should go.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Rammohan Roy | 1772–1833; “Raja” from Akbar II; died at Bristol |
| Tuhfat-ul-Muwahhidin | c. 1803–04, Persian (Arabic preface) |
| Atmiya Sabha | 1814/15, Calcutta |
| Brahmo Sabha | 20 August 1828 |
| Sati ban | Regulation XVII, 4 December 1829, Lord William Bentinck |
| Dharma Sabha | 1830, Radhakanta Deb, against the sati ban |
| Tattvabodhini Sabha | 1839, Debendranath Tagore |
| First split | 1866: Adi Brahmo Samaj (Debendranath) vs Brahmo Samaj of India (Keshab) |
| Native Marriage Act | 1872; girls 14, boys 18; no polygamy |
| Sadharan Brahmo Samaj | 15 May 1878; Ananda Mohan Bose, Sivanath Sastri |
| Naba Bidhan | 1880, Keshab |
| Young Bengal | Derozio, Hindu College; removed 1831 |
| Prarthana Samaj | 1867, Bombay, Atmaram Pandurang; Ranade, Bhandarkar |
Key Takeaways
- Reform began in Bengal because Company rule, English education and the press reached Calcutta first.
- Rammohan Roy joined reason with scripture. His Brahmo Sabha (1828) and the anti-sati campaign (1829 ban) set the pattern for later reform.
- The Brahmo Samaj split in 1866 (Adi vs Brahmo Samaj of India) and 1878 (Sadharan), both over the pace of social reform.
- The Prarthana Samaj (1867) carried theistic reform to Bombay, rooted in Maharashtrian bhakti, with Ranade as its leading figure.
- The movements were small and elite, but they created the public sphere in which nationalism grew.
What’s Next
- Arya Samaj, Ramakrishna Mission and Theosophy: the “revivalist” strand that looked to the Vedas and Vedanta
- Women’s Emancipation and Caste Reform: sati, widow remarriage and the laws that followed
- Indian Thinkers: Rammohan, Vivekananda and others for Mains GS-IV
- National Movement (1885–1919): how reform fed into early nationalism