Polity
Local Government: 73rd and 74th Amendments
The 73rd Amendment: Panchayati Raj Institutions
Part IX (Articles 243–243O) and the Eleventh Schedule: Gram Sabha, three tiers, reservation, SEC, SFC, compulsory vs voluntary provisions, and key court cases.
Prerequisites
- Evolution of Local Government in India: why the 73rd Amendment was needed
- Directive Principles and Fundamental Duties: Article 40, which Part IX finally put into effect
- Constitutional Bodies: the Finance Commission (Art 280) and Election Commission, national cousins of the SFC and SEC
The Hook: Four Ballots, One Booth
Connect
In the February 2025 panchayat polls in Chhattisgarh, a voter in a village of Dhamtari or Jashpur cast several ballots at once: for a Panch, for the Sarpanch, for a Janpad Panchayat member and for a Zila Panchayat member. Nearly half of the people elected that month were women, many from reserved seats.
None of that depended on the goodwill of the state government of the day. It was required by Part IX of the Constitution. Which parts of this system does the Constitution make compulsory, and which does it leave to each state?
Why it matters: Part IX is one of the most article-heavy topics in Prelims (“Article 243D deals with…”, “minimum age 21”, “intermediate tier may be skipped below 20 lakh”). Mains asks about devolution, finances and women’s leadership.
The 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 at a Glance
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Added | Part IX, “The Panchayats”, Articles 243 to 243O |
| Added | Eleventh Schedule, 29 subjects |
| Amended | Article 280(3)(bb): the Union Finance Commission to suggest measures to augment state funds for panchayats, on the basis of SFC recommendations |
| In force | 24 April 1993 (National Panchayati Raj Day) |
| Effect | Gave panchayats constitutional status and put them in the justiciable part of the Constitution. State laws had to conform within one year (Art 243N) |
Local government is still a State subject
“Local government” remains Entry 5 of the State List. Part IX does not make panchayats a Union matter. It sets a binding minimum framework, and each state passes its own Panchayati Raj Act within it. Chhattisgarh’s is the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993.
Part IX Article by Article
| Article | Subject | Key content |
|---|---|---|
| 243 | Definitions | “Gram Sabha”, “Panchayat”, “village”, “intermediate level”, “Panchayat area” |
| 243A | Gram Sabha (ग्राम सभा) | Body of all persons on the electoral rolls of a village; exercises powers the state legislature gives it |
| 243B | Constitution of panchayats | Three tiers: village, intermediate, district. A state with a population not exceeding 20 lakh may skip the intermediate tier |
| 243C | Composition | All members of all tiers directly elected. Chairpersons of intermediate and district tiers elected indirectly (by and from the elected members). Village chairperson elected as the state decides |
| 243D | Reservation | SC and ST seats in proportion to population; not less than one-third of seats (including SC/ST seats) for women; same rules for chairpersons’ offices; rotation; state may reserve for backward classes (243D(6)) |
| 243E | Duration | Five years from the first meeting. On dissolution, election within six months. A body elected after premature dissolution serves only the remainder of the term |
| 243F | Disqualification | Same as for the state legislature, but minimum age is 21, not 25. Disputes decided by an authority set by state law |
| 243G | Powers and functions | Panchayats as institutions of self-government; plans for economic development and social justice; the Eleventh Schedule subjects, as the state legislature decides |
| 243H | Finances | State may authorise taxes, duties, tolls and fees; assign state taxes; give grants-in-aid from the state’s Consolidated Fund |
| 243I | State Finance Commission | Constituted by the Governor within one year of the Amendment and then every five years; reviews panchayat finances |
| 243J | Audit | Accounts and audit as provided by state law |
| 243K | State Election Commission | Superintendence of panchayat elections and electoral rolls. State Election Commissioner appointed by the Governor; removable only like a High Court judge |
| 243L | Union Territories | Applies to UTs as the President directs |
| 243M | Exempted areas | Not applicable to Fifth Schedule Scheduled Areas, Sixth Schedule tribal areas, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Mizoram, hill areas of Manipur with District Councils, and Darjeeling (Gorkha Hill Council). Parliament may extend it to Scheduled Areas (done by PESA, 1996) |
| 243N | Existing laws | Inconsistent state laws continue until amended or one year, whichever is earlier |
| 243O | Courts barred | No court can question delimitation or seat allotment laws; panchayat elections can be challenged only by an election petition |
Compulsory vs Voluntary Provisions
This is the single most tested way of slicing Part IX.
| Compulsory (every state must) | Voluntary (a state may) |
|---|---|
| Organise a Gram Sabha in every village or group of villages | Decide the powers of the Gram Sabha |
| Three tiers (except states up to 20 lakh population) | Decide how the village chairperson (Sarpanch) is elected |
| Direct election of members at all three levels | Give representation to MPs, MLAs and MLCs, and to lower-tier chairpersons, in higher tiers |
| Indirect election of intermediate and district chairpersons | Reserve seats and chairpersons’ posts for backward classes |
| Minimum age 21 to contest | Devolve Eleventh Schedule subjects, i.e. the real powers and functions |
| SC/ST reservation in proportion to population | Grant financial powers: taxes, duties, tolls, fees |
| At least one-third seats and chair posts for women | Reserve more than one-third for women (21 states and 2 UTs give 50%, per Ministry of Panchayati Raj replies, 2023–25) |
| Five-year term; election within six months of dissolution | |
| A State Election Commission | |
| A State Finance Commission every five years |
The heart of the debate
Everything about existence and representation is compulsory. Everything about power (functions, taxation, Gram Sabha powers) is voluntary. That is why scholars say the Amendment created a “constitutional shell” that each state fills, or leaves empty, as it chooses.
The Eleventh Schedule (29 Subjects)
Grouped for memory (the Schedule itself numbers them 1 to 29):
| Group | Subjects |
|---|---|
| Agriculture and land | Agriculture and extension; land improvement, land reforms, consolidation, soil conservation; minor irrigation, water management, watershed development; animal husbandry, dairying, poultry; fisheries |
| Forest and energy | Social and farm forestry; minor forest produce; fuel and fodder; rural electrification; non-conventional energy |
| Industry and markets | Small-scale industries including food processing; khadi, village and cottage industries; markets and fairs |
| Infrastructure | Rural housing; drinking water; roads, culverts, bridges, ferries, waterways; maintenance of community assets |
| Education and culture | Education including primary and secondary schools; technical training and vocational education; adult and non-formal education; libraries; cultural activities |
| Health and welfare | Health and sanitation (hospitals, PHCs, dispensaries); family welfare; women and child development; social welfare (including persons with disabilities); welfare of weaker sections, especially SCs and STs; poverty alleviation programmes; public distribution system |
What Part IX Has Achieved
- Regular elections across nearly all states under State Election Commissions.
- Scale: about 2.6 lakh panchayats and over 30 lakh elected representatives (Ministry of Panchayati Raj figures, 2025; totals vary with each round of state elections).
- Women’s leadership: nearly half of all panchayat representatives are women (official estimates range from about 46% to about 50%, 2025). No legislature in India comes close.
- SC/ST presence in local office in proportion to population.
- Fiscal transfers through the Union Finance Commission (Art 280(3)(bb)):
| Finance Commission | Period | Grants to local bodies |
|---|---|---|
| 15th (N.K. Singh) | 2021–26 | ₹4,36,361 crore in all, including about ₹2.37 lakh crore for rural bodies, about ₹1.21 lakh crore for urban bodies and ₹70,051 crore health grants |
| 16th (Arvind Panagariya) | 2026–31 | About ₹7.91 lakh crore in all: about ₹4.35 lakh crore for rural and about ₹3.56 lakh crore for urban local bodies (report tabled 1 February 2026) |
Key Supreme Court Judgments
| Case | Year | Held |
|---|---|---|
| Kishansing Tomar v. Municipal Corporation of Ahmedabad | 2006 | Elections to local bodies must be completed before the term expires; the SEC should enjoy independence like the Election Commission of India in its sphere, and states must cooperate with it |
| K. Krishna Murthy v. Union of India | 2010 | Upheld Arts 243D(6) and 243T(6) (backward class reservation), but such reservation needs empirical justification and the vertical reservation for SC/ST/OBC together should not normally exceed 50% |
| Rajbala v. State of Haryana | 2015 | Upheld Haryana’s minimum educational qualification and other conditions for panchayat candidates |
| Vikas Kishanrao Gawali v. State of Maharashtra | 2021 | Laid down the “triple test” for OBC reservation in local bodies: (1) a dedicated commission to study backwardness, (2) local body-wise proportion fixed on its findings, (3) total SC+ST+OBC reservation not above 50% |
Analysis for Mains: The Unfinished Agenda
The “3 Fs”: Functions, Funds, Functionaries
- Functions: many states have transferred Eleventh Schedule subjects on paper only. Line departments still run schools, health centres and irrigation.
- Funds: own-source revenue (property tax, fees) is tiny; panchayats depend on tied grants from the Union and states. SFC reports are often delayed or not acted on.
- Functionaries: panchayats rarely control the staff (teachers, health workers, engineers) who deliver the devolved subjects.
Other problems
- Weak Gram Sabhas: low attendance, irregular meetings, decisions taken by the Sarpanch and secretary.
- Proxy representation (“Sarpanch-pati” or “Pradhan-pati”): male relatives exercising the powers of elected women. An advisory committee of the Ministry of Panchayati Raj chaired by Sushil Kumar (constituted 2023, report early 2025) recommended exemplary penalties for proven proxy cases, public oath-taking in the Gram Sabha and women’s ombudspersons.
- Bureaucratic control: the Collector and Chief Executive Officer often dominate; states can suspend or remove Sarpanchs.
- Parallel bodies: user committees and scheme-specific societies bypass the elected panchayat.
- Capacity: few staff, little technical help for planning (Gram Panchayat Development Plans).
What has worked
- Kerala’s People’s Plan Campaign (1996): a large share of the state’s plan funds was devolved to local bodies, with Gram Sabhas drafting plans. Often cited as India’s best devolution model.
- Women’s leadership has shifted local priorities towards drinking water, sanitation and schooling (widely reported in research on reserved seats).
- Finance Commission grants flowing directly to panchayats have grown sharply since the 14th Commission.
Chhattisgarh angle
Chhattisgarh reserves 50% of panchayat seats for women (since 2008), changed its OBC reservation rules in 2024 after the Supreme Court’s triple test, and held three-phase panchayat polls in February 2025. Its tribal north and south also run under PESA. Use one or two of these facts in a Mains answer. Details: Three-Tier Panchayati Raj in Chhattisgarh and State Election Commission and State Finance Commission.
Memory Tricks
Part IX as an alphabet ladder (243A to 243O)
A - Assembly of villagers (Gram Sabha) · B - Build three tiers · C - Composition · D - Divide seats (reservation) · E - Expiry (duration) · F - Fail to qualify (disqualification) · G - Give powers · H - Have money (taxes) · I - Income body (SFC) · J - Judge the accounts (audit) · K - Kaun jeetega? (SEC) · L - Little territories (UTs) · M - Mountains and tribal areas exempt · N - No old laws after one year · O - Off-limits to courts
The pair that decides most MCQs: I = Income (Finance Commission), K = Kaun jeetega (Election Commission).
Numbers to lock in
- 21: minimum age
- 20 lakh: below this, no intermediate tier needed
- 1/3: minimum for women
- 5: years (term, and SFC interval)
- 6: months to hold election after dissolution
- 29: subjects in the Eleventh Schedule
- 1: year for state laws to conform (Art 243N)
Don’t Confuse
| This | vs | That |
|---|---|---|
| Art 243 — definitions | vs | Art 243A — Gram Sabha |
| Art 243I — State Finance Commission (panchayats) | vs | Art 243K — State Election Commission (panchayats) |
| Art 243Y / 243ZA — SFC / SEC for municipalities | vs | Art 243I / 243K — SFC / SEC for panchayats |
| Eleventh Schedule — 29 subjects, panchayats | vs | Twelfth Schedule — 18 subjects, municipalities |
| Part IX — panchayats (73rd, 1992) | vs | Part IXB — co-operative societies (97th Amendment, 2011) |
| Members of all tiers: direct election | vs | Chairpersons of intermediate and district tiers: indirect |
| Art 280(3)(bb) — Union FC on panchayats | vs | Art 280(3)(c) — Union FC on municipalities |
Common Mistakes
MCQ traps
- “The 73rd Amendment made local government a Union subject.” False. It remains Entry 5, State List.
- “Reservation for OBCs in panchayats is compulsory.” False. Art 243D(6) makes it optional.
- “50% reservation for women is a constitutional requirement.” False. The Constitution says at least one-third; 50% is by state law.
- “The State Election Commissioner is appointed by the Chief Minister / President.” False. By the Governor; removed only like a High Court judge.
- “Part IX applies to all of India, including Nagaland and Mizoram.” False. Art 243M exempts them, along with Meghalaya, Manipur’s hill areas, Darjeeling and Scheduled and tribal areas.
- “Minimum age for panchayat membership is 25.” False. It is 21 (Art 243F).
Practice
All questions below are original practice questions written in CGPSC style. They are not previous-year questions.
Level 1: Foundation
- Part IX of the Constitution covers Articles ______ to ______.
- A state may skip the intermediate tier if its population does not exceed ______.
- The State Election Commissioner can be removed only in the manner of a ______.
Answers
- 243 to 243O.
- 20 lakh.
- Judge of a High Court.
Level 2: Prelims MCQs
Q1. Consider the following statements regarding the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act:
- It is compulsory for every state to reserve seats for backward classes in panchayats.
- Chairpersons of panchayats at the intermediate and district levels are elected indirectly.
- A panchayat constituted after premature dissolution continues only for the remainder of the original five-year term.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer and explanation
(b) 2 and 3 only. Backward class reservation is optional under Art 243D(6), so statement 1 is wrong. Art 243C requires indirect election of intermediate and district chairpersons. Art 243E(4) limits a body elected after premature dissolution to the remainder of the term.
Q2. Match List I (Article) with List II (Subject):
| List I | List II |
|---|---|
| A. 243A | 1. State Finance Commission |
| B. 243D | 2. Gram Sabha |
| C. 243I | 3. State Election Commission |
| D. 243K | 4. Reservation of seats |
- (a) A-2, B-4, C-3, D-1
- (b) A-2, B-4, C-1, D-3
- (c) A-4, B-2, C-1, D-3
- (d) A-2, B-1, C-4, D-3
Answer and explanation
(b) A-2, B-4, C-1, D-3. 243A Gram Sabha, 243D reservation, 243I State Finance Commission, 243K State Election Commission. Option (a) swaps I and K, the most common slip.
Q3. Part IX of the Constitution does not, of its own force, apply to which of the following?
- Mizoram
- Fifth Schedule Scheduled Areas
- Darjeeling district (for the area under the Gorkha Hill Council)
- Union Territories, until the President so directs
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 1, 2 and 3 only
- (c) 2 and 4 only
- (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer and explanation
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4. Art 243M exempts Mizoram (with Nagaland and Meghalaya), Scheduled Areas and tribal areas, and the Darjeeling hill areas. Art 243L applies Part IX to UTs only as the President directs by public notification.
Q4. Under the Constitution, the State Finance Commission for panchayats is constituted by:
- (a) The Union Finance Commission, every five years
- (b) The Governor, every five years
- (c) The State Legislature, every three years
- (d) The Chief Minister, as and when required
Answer and explanation
(b). Art 243I: the Governor constitutes the SFC within one year of the 73rd Amendment’s commencement and thereafter at the expiry of every fifth year. Its report goes to the Governor, who lays it before the state legislature.
Q5. The “triple test” for reservation of seats for backward classes in local bodies was laid down by the Supreme Court in:
- (a) K. Krishna Murthy v. Union of India
- (b) Indra Sawhney v. Union of India
- (c) Vikas Kishanrao Gawali v. State of Maharashtra
- (d) Kishansing Tomar v. Municipal Corporation of Ahmedabad
Answer and explanation
(c). Vikas Kishanrao Gawali (2021) set the triple test: a dedicated commission, local body-wise proportions on its findings, and a 50% ceiling on total vertical reservation. K. Krishna Murthy (2010) had earlier upheld such reservation in principle.
Level 3: Mains Answer Writing
Q1. (60 words) Distinguish between the compulsory and voluntary provisions of the 73rd Amendment.
Model answer outline
- Compulsory: Gram Sabha; three tiers (except below 20 lakh population); direct election of members; indirect election of intermediate and district chairpersons; age 21; SC/ST and one-third women reservation; five-year term; SEC and SFC.
- Voluntary: powers of Gram Sabha; backward class reservation; representation of MPs and MLAs; devolution of Eleventh Schedule subjects; taxation powers.
- One line: structure is mandatory, power is optional.
Q2. (150–200 words) “Three decades after the 73rd Amendment, panchayats are constitutionally secure but functionally weak.” Discuss.
Model answer outline
- Intro: the 73rd Amendment (in force 24 April 1993) gave panchayats constitutional status through Part IX and the Eleventh Schedule.
- Secure: regular elections under SECs (Kishansing Tomar, 2006); reservation for SC/ST and women, with nearly half of representatives now women; SFCs and growing Union FC grants (16th FC: about ₹4.35 lakh crore for rural bodies, 2026–31).
- Weak: the 3Fs (functions, funds, functionaries) left to states; tied grants; tiny own revenue; weak Gram Sabhas; proxy representation; bureaucratic control and parallel bodies.
- Way forward: activity mapping of Eleventh Schedule subjects; timely SFC reports; untied funds; cadre of panchayat staff; Gram Sabha social audits; penalties for proxy leadership (Sushil Kumar committee, 2025).
- Chhattisgarh angle: 50% women’s reservation and PESA Rules (2022) for Scheduled Areas show both progress and implementation gaps.
- Conclusion: the Constitution secured existence; real self-government needs states to devolve power.
Quick Revision Table
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Part / Articles | Part IX, Arts 243–243O |
| Schedule | Eleventh, 29 subjects |
| In force | 24 April 1993 |
| Gram Sabha | Art 243A; all registered voters of the village |
| Three tiers | Art 243B; intermediate optional below 20 lakh population |
| Chairpersons | Intermediate and district: indirect; village: as state decides |
| Reservation | Art 243D; SC/ST by population; women at least 1/3; BC optional |
| Term | Art 243E; 5 years; poll within 6 months of dissolution |
| Minimum age | 21 (Art 243F) |
| SFC / SEC | Art 243I / 243K |
| Exempt areas | Art 243M: Scheduled and tribal areas, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Manipur hills, Darjeeling |
| Court bar | Art 243O; election petition only |
| Union FC link | Art 280(3)(bb) |
| 50% women | 21 states + 2 UTs by state law (MoPR, 2023–25) |
| Triple test | Vikas Kishanrao Gawali (2021) |
Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways
- Part IX (Arts 243–243O) and the Eleventh Schedule (29 subjects) came into force on 24 April 1993.
- Elections, reservation, term, SEC and SFC are compulsory; powers and taxation are left to the states.
- Learn the article letters A to O in order; I = Finance, K = Election is the most tested pair.
- Local government is still a State subject; Part IX is a binding minimum.
- For Mains, analyse through the 3Fs and cite one judgment and one Chhattisgarh fact.
What’s Next
- The 74th Amendment: Urban Local Bodies: the parallel framework for towns and cities
- PESA, 1996 and Tribal Self-Rule: how Part IX reaches Scheduled Areas through Art 243M
- Three-Tier Panchayati Raj in Chhattisgarh: the state law in action
- Public Finance: Finance Commission transfers in the wider fiscal picture
Advertisement